Bonus Content: Falls and Other Hazards to Workers Removing Snow from Rooftops and Other Elevated Surfaces
NOTE: Snow removal is typically a maintenance activity regulated under Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) general industry standard 29 CFR 1910 (see general industry fall protection compliance guidance, Directive STD 01-01-013, for work from elevated surfaces). However, on construction sites where snow must be removed in order to begin or continue construction work, OSHA’s standards at 29 CFR 1926 apply, including residential construction sites (see fall protection compliance guidance, Directive STD 03-11-002).
Every year, workers are killed or seriously injured performing snow or ice removal from rooftops and other building structures, such as decks. OSHA has investigated 16 such serious injuries or fatalities in the past 10 years—all of which could have been prevented. Snow removal is performed for a number of reasons, such as to prevent overloading and collapse, or for construction or repair of decking or roofs. Workers often climb directly onto the roof or structures and use equipment such as shovels, snow rakes, snow blowers, ladders, etc. Other times, these operations may be performed from the ground level using snow rakes. Aerial lifts are sometimes used to access roofs and apply de-icing materials. Snow-removal operations are often performed under extreme weather conditions (e.g., cold, high winds, icy surfaces). Building maintenance workers or others who perform these activities may have little experience or training on the hazards of such work—and those performing snow-removal operations are exposed to many serious hazards.
Based on the findings of OSHA investigations, falls cause the most worker fatalities and injuries during rooftop snow removal. Workers may fall off roof edges, through skylights, and from ladders and aerial lifts. Workers also may be injured or killed by a roof collapse. Examples of incidents investigated by OSHA include:
- A worker was removing snow from a roof when he lost his balance and slid off the roof. He fell and struck his head on construction materials that were stored below and sustained a fatal head injury.
- A worker was laying grid lines and shoveling snow on a second-floor deck. An elevator shaft opening was covered with a plastic tarp, with temporary guardrails installed around a portion of the shaft opening. The worker, who was not wearing any fall protection, fell 30 feet through the unguarded portion of the elevator shaft opening and died.
- 4 workers were building a second-floor room addition. One was standing on a 12-foot aluminum ladder, attempting to clean snow from a low-slope roof, 10 feet above ground. The feet of the ladder slid and the worker fell, striking his head on the ladder and then on the concrete driveway. He died several days later.
- A worker shoveling snow from the roof of a residential construction site fell from a height of more than 11 feet and was fatally impaled by a scaffold upright.
Workers removing snow face other significant hazards in addition to falls, including:
- Amputations, eye injuries, and other injuries associated with the use of snowblowers and other mechanized equipment;
- Collapses or tip-overs when using aerial lifts;
- Entrapment and suffocation under falling snow drifts or snow piles;
- Shock/electrocution hazards from contacting power lines or damaged extension cords;
- Frostbite or hypothermia from cold and windy conditions; and
- Musculoskeletal injuries from overexertion.
Under the OSH Act’s general duty clause, employers have a duty to protect workers from recognized serious hazards in the workplace, including hazards associated with snow removal from roofs. This alert describes the steps you can take to prevent injuries and deaths from these hazards.
PLAN AHEAD FOR SAFE SNOW REMOVAL FROM ROOFS
Before snow starts to accumulate, think about what will be needed to safely remove snow from roofs or other elevated surfaces.
- Can snow be removed without workers going onto the roof?
- Are there any hazards on the roof that might become hidden by snow and need to be marked so that workers can see them (skylights, roof drains, vents, etc.)?
- Based on the building’s layout, how should the snow be removed to prevent unbalanced loading?
- What are the maximum load limits of the roof and how do they compare with the estimated total weight of snow, snow-removal equipment, and workers on the roof?
- What tools, equipment, protective devices, clothing, and footwear will workers need?
- What type of fall protection will be used to protect workers on roofs and other elevated surfaces?
- What training will workers need to work safely?
- How will mechanized snow-removal equipment be safely elevated to the roof?
- How will you protect people on the ground from snow and ice falling off the roof during removal operations?
PREVENTING FALLS DURING SNOW REMOVAL
Working on a roof with snow, ice, or wind carries risk of a fall on the roof itself, a fall off the roof to the ground below, or a fall through a snow-covered skylight—all of which are often fatal. Employers should protect their workers from these hazardous work conditions by:
- Using snow-removal methods that do not involve workers going on roofs, when and where possible;
- Evaluating loads exerted on roof or structure (e.g., total weight of snow, workers, and equipment used) compared to the load limit of the roof;
- Requiring that workers use fall protection equipment; and
- Ensuring that workers use ladders and aerial lifts safely.
Remove Snow Without Going on the Roof
Whenever possible, use methods to clear ice and snow without having workers go on the roof. For example:
- Use ladders to apply de-icing materials, and
- Use snow rakes or drag lines from the ground.
These methods, too, can pose hazards to workers. Read the sections on “Use Ladders Safely,” “Use Aerial Lifts Safely,” and “Avoid Electrical Hazards.”
Evaluate Load Bearing on the Roof or Structure
Before workers access a roof or other elevated structure, the employer should confirm that the workers’ weight and any equipment used can be supported by the roof or structure without causing a collapse. Workers always should use caution by remaining alert to unexpected sounds or movement around surfaces that have been weighed down by snow (or water from melted snow), because these surfaces could collapse.
Shoveling or raking a roof without using the proper procedures can also increase the risk of roof collapse by creating an unbalanced load on the roof. To prevent unbalanced loading during snow removal, workers should:
- Remove snow uniformly across the roof, and
- Avoid making snow piles on the roof.
WHAT IS SNOW LOAD AND HOW MUCH SNOW CAN A ROOF SUPPORT?
Snow load is the weight of the snow (generally reported in pounds per square foot). The weight of snow will vary depending on its water content. Snow load on the ground can provide a rough indication of roof snow load, but roof snow loads also depend upon factors such as melting and re-freezing of snow and ice, drifting, roof slope, the type of roof, and design features.
The amount of weight that a roof can safely support is based on local building code requirements and should be available within the design specifications for your building. If the structure or roof has structural deterioration, the roof might support less weight than would otherwise be expected.
- National snow load information compiled by the U.S. Forest Service includes ground snow load information and links to state-specific data.
- National Weather Service snow analysis data (searchable by region, state, city, and zip code).
- S. Department of Agriculture, National Resources Conservation Service, SNOwpack TELemetry (SNOTEL) snow data for states in the western United States shows examples of ground snow load calculations.
For more in-depth information on roof snow load calculations and requirements, see American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures.
Protect People on the Ground during Snow Removal
Bystanders and workers on the ground removing snow from a roof can become trapped under snow falling from the roof and could suffocate.
- Mark a safe work zone in the area where snow is to be removed (e.g., keep people back 10 feet from the point where snow is expected to be blown or fall).
- Wear eye and head protection, especially when removing ice.
- When using snow rakes, remove small amounts of snow at a time.
Use Required Fall Protection
Falls cause most of the deaths and severe injuries that occur during snow-removal operations. OSHA standards require employers to evaluate hazards and protect workers from falls when working at heights of 4 feet or more above a lower level (1910.23) or 6 feet or more for construction work (1926.501). If workers will access roofs and other elevated surfaces to clear snow:
- Train workers on fall hazards and the proper use of fall protection equipment, as required by 1910.132(f)(1) and 1926.503(a)(1).
- Provide and ensure that workers use fall protection equipment if they are removing snow in areas that are not adequately guarded (e.g., with a guardrail system or cover), as required by STD 01-01-013 and 1926.501(b) (see box: “Information on Fall Protection” and “Note”).
- Instruct workers who wear personal fall protection equipment to put on their harnesses and buckle them snugly before mounting the roof.
- Have a plan for rescuing a fallen worker caught by a fall protection system, as required by 1926.502(d)(20).
- Remove or clearly mark rooftop or landscaping features that could become trip hazards.
Information on Fall Protection
Personal fall arrest systems and guardrails are among the most commonly used forms of fall protection for work on roofs.
- Typical personal fall arrest systems involve an anchor point; a full-body harness; and a connector, such as a retractable lifeline or a shock-absorbing lanyard. Anchor points must be able to support at least 5,000 pounds for each worker attached to it (1926.502(d)(15)) or maintain a safety factor of at least 2 (twice the impact load) under the supervision of a qualified person (1926.502(d)(15)(i) and (ii)). OSHA believes that anchorages available on the market will meet the strength requirements if they are installed as per the manufacturer’s instruction.
Guardrails must be 42 inches high, with a mid-rail (1910.23(e), 1926.502(b))
Use Ladders Safely
Workers may use ladders to access rooftops for snow removal. Workers should not use a snow rake or shovel while on a ladder because this greatly increases the risk of losing one’s balance and falling.
To prevent falls from ladders used for accessing roofs:
- Make sure workers know the route and method they should use to get up and down from a roof in a way that minimizes the risk of falling. The safest location for the ladder might not be the most obvious one, or an alternate method (e.g., an access door or lift) might be available to get on the roof. Safe roof access is as important as having effective fall protection while on the roof.
- Ensure that workers follow safe practices when working on ladders:
- Ensure that the ladder has level and secure footing, as required by (1910.25(d)(2)(xix), 1910.26(c)(3)(iii), and 1926.1053(b)(6).
- Check the ladder rungs for ice. A slippery step can cause a fatal fall.
- Position the ladder at the correct angle. Place the base of the ladder a distance from the vertical wall equal to one-fourth the working length of the ladder, as required by 1910.25(d)(2)(i), 1910.26(c)(3)(i), and 1926.1053(b)(5)(i).
- Clean snow from shoes or boots before mounting the ladder.
- Extend the ladder 3 feet above the upper level (i.e., the roof). If that is not possible, use ladder rail extensions and secure the ladder to prevent it from slipping or tipping, as required by 1926.1053(b)(1) and 1910.25(d)(2)(xv).
- If using an A-frame ladder, do not stand on the top 2 steps—that location is not stable.
- Always maintain 3 points of contact with the ladder (2 feet and 1 hand, alternating with 2 hands and 1 foot), as required by 1926.1053(b)(21).
- Keep the centerline of the body inside the ladder rails. Do not lean or reach so that the body extends outside the rails. That position is unstable and could lead to a fall.
- Do not carry heavy or bulky objects or loads up a ladder, as required by 1926.1053(b)(22). which could cause loss of balance and falling. To transport such equipment, workers should climb up the ladder first, and then pull the equipment up to the working level with a rope or other appropriate hoisting method.
Use Aerial Lifts Safely
Aerial lifts may be used during snow-removal operations to transport de-icing equipment or to push or scrape snow from a roof. Take the following steps to ensure safe use of this equipment (also see “Avoid Electrical Hazards”):
- Make sure that workers who operate aerial lifts are properly trained in the safe use of the equipment, as required by 1910.67(c)(2)(ii) and 1926.454.
- Maintain and operate elevating work platforms according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
- Never override hydraulic, mechanical, or electrical safety devices.
- Never move the equipment with workers in an elevated platform unless this is permitted by the manufacturer, as required by 1926.453(b)(2)(viii) and 1910.67(c)(2)(viii).
- Do not allow workers to position themselves between the rails of the basket and overhead hazards, such as joists and beams, because movement of the lift could crush the worker(s).
- Provide and ensure that workers use a body harness or restraining belt with a lanyard attached to the boom or basket to prevent them from being ejected or pulled from the basket, as required by 1910.67(c)(2)(v) and 1926.453(b)(2)(v).
- Do not allow workers to climb or stand on the lift’s railing.
- Set the brakes and use wheel chocks when on an incline, as required by 1910.67(c)(2)(vii) and 1926.453(b)(2)(vii).
- Use outriggers, if provided.
- Do not exceed the load limits of the equipment, as required by 1910.67(c)(2)(vi) and 1926.453(b)(2)(vi). Allow for the combined weight of the worker, tools, and materials when calculating load.
PREVENTING INJURIES WHEN USING MECHANIZED EQUIPMENT ON ROOFS
Unsafe use of mechanized equipment, such as snowblowers, while removing snow from roofs may cause injuries such as amputations and eye injuries. Accidents also can happen when workers move equipment used for snow removal to the rooftop.
- Train workers and ensure that they read, understand, and follow all manufacturers’ instructions for the safe use of all mechanical equipment, as required by 1926.21(b)(2).
- Provide and ensure that workers wear eye protection, as required by 1910.133(a)(2) and 1926.102(a)(1). Items thrown by powered equipment can ricochet and cause serious eye damage.
- Ensure that workers use safe work practices. For example:
- Raise materials to the roof using equipment lifts, winches, pull ropes, or related equipment.
- Do not use powered equipment near the edge of any roof. Some snowblower manufacturers recommend maintaining a distance of 15 feet from the roof edge.
- Operate snow-removal equipment at reduced speeds due to slippery roof conditions.
- Keep hands out of the collection or discharge openings on powered snow-removal equipment—equipment such as snowblowers can cause amputations! If equipment becomes clogged, shut it off, wait until all moving parts have stopped, then use a clearing tool to unclog, as required by 1926.302(c).
AVOID ELECTRICAL HAZARDS
Workers may face electrical hazards such as electrocution and electric shock from power lines or snow-removal equipment.
- Use extreme caution when working near power lines. Always treat power lines, wires, and other conductors as energized, even if they are down or appear to be insulated.
- Maintain a distance of at least 10 feet from any power line, as required by 1910.333(c)(3).
- Make sure that all electrically powered equipment is grounded (third prong on a 3-prong plug is not missing) and includes a ground-fault circuit interrupter (GFCI) in the circuit, as required by 1910.304(b)(3), 1910.334(a)(3), and 1926.404(b)(1)(ii).
- When using snow rakes, use extendable, nonconductive poles; and designate workers as monitors to maintain 10 feet from snow rakes to overhead power lines.
- When using aerial lifts, maintain a minimum clearance of at least 10 feet from the nearest energized overhead lines, as required by 1910.333(c)(3).
- If servicing equipment becomes necessary, isolate the energy following lockout/tagout procedures (for example, 1 method is to disconnect the spark plug wire and ground it against the machine), as required by 1910.147 and 1926.417.
AVOIDING OTHER HAZARDS
Exposure to cold can cause injury and illness in workers removing snow. Cold exposure can cause frostbite (freezing in the deep layers of skin and tissue) and hypothermia (drop of body temperature to less than 95 ̊F). For information on how to prevent these situations, see OSHA’s Safety and Health Guide on Cold Stress.
Physical exertion during snow removal also can cause injuries and illnesses. Snow removal can be strenuous, particularly because cold weather can be taxing on the body, and can create the potential for exhaustion, dehydration, back injuries, or heart attacks, as well as increase the risk of falls. Make sure that workers take steps to minimize overexertion and help prevent injuries.
- Scoop or push small amounts of snow at a time. Use a smaller shovel or take smaller scoops of snow if the snow is wet and heavy.
- Use proper form if lifting is necessary: keep the back straight and lift with the legs.
- Do not overload the snowblower; let it operate at a modest speed.
- Take frequent breaks and drink fluids (avoid caffeine or alcohol).
Help for Employers
OSHA’s On-Site Consultation Program offers free and confidential advice to small businesses with fewer than 250 workers at a site and no more than 500 employees nationwide. The program provides free, on-site compliance assistance to help employers identify and correct job hazards as well as improve injury and illness prevention programs. On-site consultation services are separate from enforcement and do not result in penalties or citations.
To locate the OSHA consultation office nearest you, visit www.osha.gov or call 1-800-321-OSHA (6742).
This hazard alert is not a standard or regulation, and it creates no new legal obligations. It contains recommendations as well as descriptions of mandatory safety and health standards. The recommendations are advisory in nature, informational in content, and are intended to assist employers in providing a safe and healthful workplace. The OSH Act requires employers to comply with safety and health standards and regulations promulgated by OSHA or by a state with an OSHA-approved state plan. In addition, the Act’s general duty clause, Section 5(a)(1), requires employers to provide their employees with a workplace free from recognized hazards likely to cause death or serious physical harm.
This article was published in the January 2020 issue of Insulation Outlook magazine. Copyright © 2020 National Insulation Association. All rights reserved. The contents of this website and Insulation Outlook magazine may not be reproduced in any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission of the publisher and NIA. Any unauthorized duplication is strictly prohibited and would violate NIA’s copyright and may violate other copyright agreements that NIA has with authors and partners. Contact email@example.com to reprint or reproduce this content.
Disclaimer: Unless specifically noted at the beginning of the article, the content, calculations, and opinions expressed by the author(s) of any article in Insulation Outlook are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of NIA. The appearance of an article, advertisement, and/or product or service information in Insulation Outlook does not constitute an endorsement of such products or services by NIA. Every effort will be made to avoid the use or mention of specific product brand names in featured magazine articles.