Industrial Case Study: Insulating a Cogeneration Boiler

Darrell Peil

Darrell Peil holds the position of Business Development Mgr./Commercial & Industrial for Knauf Insulation (www.knaufinsulation.com), serving North America. Currently a member of ASHRAE and ASTM, he serves on several committees related to mechanical insulation, systems and components. He is the current Chair of NIA’s Technical Information Committee, a past chair of ASHRAE’s TC 1.8 Handbook Subcommittee, and a member of the editorial committee for the National Commercial and Industrial Insulation Standards manual(MICA manual). Mr. Peil has been associated with the building mechanical systems industry since 1982, holding various roles in the contracting, distribution, and manufacturing segments of the industry. During that time, he has served in several positions requiring in-depth work with business and product development, systems design, specifications, standards, and codes applying to a wide range of applications. He can be reached at darrell.peil@knaufinsulation.com.

November 1, 2018

Industrial facilities with above-ambient temperatures depend on insulation for process efficiency, system health, and personnel protection. Brace Integrated Services, a NIA Contractor member company, recently undertook a project to insulate a 2-boiler cogeneration power generation plant at an industrial facility in Ponca City, Oklahoma. The newly built facility was adding power generation from the waste heat released by the core process of making carbon black and needed appropriate insulation to ensure system integrity. This was an outdoor system that will experience rain, intense sun exposure, snow, sleet, hot and cold temperatures, ice, and high winds. The cogeneration boiler required an insulation solution that would withstand these conditions, operating temperatures between 400°F and 600°F, and thermal conductivity of ASTM C547 mineral fiber specification range.

The Challenge

Initially, a different insulation was specified for the project. Unfortunately, there was a delayed release of the piping to be insulated, putting the project behind schedule; this, in addition to the lead time for the insulation originally specified, caused the project superintendent and estimator to consider other insulation materials.

Adapting on the Go

The project team reached out to 4-State Supply, a NIA Distributor member company, to see what available materials they had that might meet project requirements. 4-State Supply had a large inventory of a 1000°F-rated fiber glass pipe insulation and the ability to order more with a short enough lead time to meet project deadlines. Cody Unick, the estimator, stated, “There was no pushback or concerns expressed by the owner in accepting… the proposed substitute for the specified material on this project.” The fiber glass pipe insulation chosen was a molded, one-piece insulation made by Knauf Insulation, a NIA Manufacturer member company; the product is made from inorganic fiber glass bonded with ECOSE Technology. Unick noted, “Lead time for the first shipment of… insulation was less than a week after placing the order. The distributor had what was needed to jump-start the project and allow us to get going.”

The type of fiber glass specified is used to insulate iron, copper, stainless steel, PVC, and CPVC piping in industrial applications, and in commercial and institutional buildings. It is suitable for hot, cold, concealed, and exposed piping systems operating at temperatures from 0°F to 1000°F (-18°C to 538°C). It has a 1-piece hinged construction and a range of sizes, which may help reduce gapping or thermal leaks. Fiber glass pipe insulation is commonly applied on power generation insulation projects, as are a range of rigid and flexible materials suitable for these temperatures. Other options would be calcium silicate, expanded perlite, and high-temperature flexible blanket insulation.

For this particular project, approximately 4 truckloads of insulation were needed in thicknesses ranging from 1 ½” to 5” thick, with pipe sizes ranging from ¾” iron pipe size (IPS) to 22” IPS. The fiber glass pipe insulation was covered with stucco-embossed aluminum banded to the systems, and pressed, preformed aluminum elbow covers for insulated 90° pipe elbows. The process to install involved an installer opening the pre-slit fiber glass and fitting it around the pipe. For piping requiring double-layer application, the inner layer is held on and closed with tie wire. The outer layer was closed and secured using the self-seal closure of an ASJ jacket. This is a standard application process that does not typically require special training for a professional quality insulation contractor.

The project is ongoing and is expected to be completed in fall 2018. Insulating this system properly will deliver efficient system operation and continued energy and operating cost savings. If the system were not insulated correctly, it would be at risk for excessive heat leaks and require excessive amounts of energy and cost to maintain proper system operation. There could also be excess amounts of condensation formation, requiring far more heat/energy input to return the condensate to steam. The properly specified and installed insulation will prevent these issues and help ensure optimal system operations.

 

 

Copyright Statement

This article was published in the November 2018 issue of Insulation Outlook magazine. Copyright © 2018 National Insulation Association. All rights reserved. The contents of this website and Insulation Outlook magazine may not be reproduced in any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission of the publisher and NIA. Any unauthorized duplication is strictly prohibited and would violate NIA’s copyright and may violate other copyright agreements that NIA has with authors and partners. Contact publisher@insulation.org to reprint or reproduce this content.

Related Articles

Case Study: Insulation Audit Leads to Big Savings

Background Honeywell’s Geismar site was established in 1967 and is currently operated by roughly 275 employees and 130 contractors. The site is responsible for producing multiple refrigerants, hydrofluoric acid, and a resin that is used in medical packaging. The various reactors, heat exchangers, steam traps, and process piping that make our processes a reality all Read Article

Case Study: Replacement of District Energy Chilled Water and High-Temperature Hot Water Distribution Line Insulation

Brown University is a school of 8,700 students and 700 faculty members in Providence, Rhode Island. The University operates a hot water and chilled water distributed energy system run off a co-generation plant. The hot and chilled water is distributed in pipes running through a system of tunnels and manholes. The existing piping was insulated Read Article

Chill Out: Maintaining Integrity of Chilled-Water Systems

A chilled-water system can be defined as a re-circulating water system using water chilled in a refrigeration machine as a source for cooling. In most commercial applications, this cooled water is used as part of an HVAC system for conditioning the temperature of the air in a room or building. We often think about the Read Article

Duke University’s Steam Systems Get New Insulation

The History of Steam Power Steam power has a long and important history. It has powered an industrial revolution, supported the growth of our largest cities, and shaped the political maps of our world. Yet, for many, it goes unnoticed.  Steam warms our homes and workplaces in winter, and even cools us in summer. Steam Read Article